All articles

Training

Threshold runs: should you go by pace or heart rate?

Your watch shows both, and they don’t always agree. Here’s what each one gets wrong, and a simple way to use them together.

You start a threshold run. Your watch says your pace is spot on. But your heart rate says you’re running too easy. Twenty minutes later, your heart rate says you’re running too hard, and your pace hasn’t changed at all. So which one should you trust?

Here’s the short answer. On a flat route on a normal day, go by pace. Watch for a heart rate that’s unusually high for you, and check that the effort still feels controlled. When hills, heat or wind make pace unreliable, let effort lead and keep an eye on heart rate. The rest of this article explains why.

The short version

  • Pace is the better target on normal days. It helps you hold a steady speed without waiting for heart rate to catch up.
  • Heart rate takes time to catch up, then keeps climbing. In one study it rose from about 88% to 92% of max over 40 minutes at the same pace.
  • Use your usual heart rate range as a guide. If it stays much higher than usual and the effort feels harder, ease off.
  • The same pace can take more effort in hills, heat or wind. On those days, run by feel and watch your heart rate.

What is threshold pace?

Your muscles produce lactate as you run, and your body uses it as fuel. Here, threshold means the fastest pace at which blood lactate stays fairly steady. Above that pace, lactate keeps rising as you continue running.1

Most runners describe threshold as “comfortably hard.” You can say a few words, but you wouldn’t want to chat. The goal is to make a faster pace feel sustainable over time.

It doesn’t take a big increase in speed to go above threshold. In a study of 10 well-trained runners, going just 0.5 km/h faster than their threshold speed was enough to make lactate keep rising. At their pace, that’s only about 8 seconds faster per kilometer, or 12 seconds per mile.2 A small increase in pace can turn a controlled threshold run into a much harder workout.

Just above threshold

8 s/km

In the 10-runner study, this small increase in pace made lactate keep rising

Heart rate drift

88% → 92%

Average heart rate as a share of max, from the start to the end of a 40-minute run

Why not just go by heart rate?

Heart rate tells you how your body is responding to a run. But it has three limits as a target for threshold workouts.

It’s slow to react. When you speed up, your heart rate takes a little while to catch up. You’ve probably seen it on your watch: in a short rep, it’s often still climbing when the rep ends. If you push harder to “get your heart rate up,” you can run the start of each rep too fast.

It drifts upward. In a 2023 study, 15 trained runners ran for 40 minutes at one steady speed based on a lab lactate test. Their oxygen use stayed almost exactly the same. Their heart rates did not.3

Same pace for 40 minutes, but heart rate kept climbing

Average heart rate and oxygen use of 15 runners, as a share of each runner’s max.

Share of maxStartAfter 40 minutes
Heart rate, average88.3%92.2%
Heart rate, range across runners84.1–91.4%88.1–95.3%
Oxygen use, average79.0%79.2%

Data: Fleckenstein et al., 2023.

Heart rate rose by about 4 percentage points of maximum heart rate on average, and by up to 8 points for one runner. For someone with a max of 190, that’s about 8 beats on average and up to 15. This is called cardiac drift, and it usually starts after 10 to 20 minutes of steady effort.4 Trying to hold heart rate at its starting value could mean slowing down as the run goes on, even at a pace where oxygen use stays steady.

That doesn’t make drift meaningless. The same runners said the run felt harder by the end. Their final blood lactate levels also varied, from 1.9 to 3.8 millimoles per liter.3 If your heart rate stays well above its usual range and the run feels harder than normal, ease off. Use that range as a guide, rather than trying to hold one exact number.

Heat makes drift worse. When people ran at a moderate, steady effort in 35 °C (95 °F) heat, their heart rates rose 19% between minute 15 and minute 45.5 Losing fluid adds to it, too: in a study of cyclists, greater fluid loss was linked to a larger rise in heart rate.6

Your threshold heart rate is personal. At the same blood lactate level in a lab test, those 15 runners started anywhere from 84% to 91% of their max heart rate.3 So a rule like “threshold is 88% of max” will be close for some runners and well off for others. Your own threshold heart rate moves around, too. When runners were tested twice, two weeks apart, the typical measurement error in threshold heart rate was about 5 beats per minute.7

Then there’s the sensor itself. In a 2017 test, a chest strap matched a medical heart monitor almost perfectly. Wrist monitors were less accurate, with results varying by brand and activity.8

Why not just go by pace?

Pace has its own problem. The effort needed to hold a pace changes with the conditions.

Hills. Running uphill takes more energy per meter. In one treadmill study, a very steep 45% slope took more than five times as much energy per meter as flat ground.9 Holding your flat threshold pace up a hill would put you far above threshold.

Heat. Warm weather slows you down at the same effort. In a study of seven big marathons, the fastest men finished 1.7% behind the course record on cool days. On hot days, they were 4.5% behind. Slower runners lost even more.10

The hotter the day, the slower the race

How much slower the top men ran than the course record. Temperatures use wet-bulb globe temperature, a heat measure that includes humidity and sun.

Cool5–10 °C · 41–50 °F1.7%
Mild10–15 °C · 50–59 °F2.5%
Warm15–20 °C · 59–68 °F3.3%
Hot20–25 °C · 68–77 °F4.5%

Data: Ely et al., 2007.

Wind, trails and tired legs all change what a pace feels like, too. And GPS pace can jump around under trees or between tall buildings. On days like these, chasing your normal threshold pace can make the workout too hard.

So which should you use?

Use each one for what it does best.

  • Pace sets the target. In cool, calm conditions, use your estimated threshold pace to keep the effort steady. Check lap pace rather than chasing every change in the GPS reading.
  • Heart rate helps you spot a harder day. Note your usual range late in similar workouts in cool weather. If it stays well above that range and the effort feels harder, slow down.
  • Feel is the check. Threshold should feel comfortably hard. It can get harder toward the end, but you should still feel in control. If you’re straining, ease off. Simple effort ratings, like a score out of 10, track training load well.11

What to follow, and when

A cheat sheet for your next threshold run.

When you’re runningGo byWhy
On flat ground in normal weatherPacePace helps you settle into a steady speed while heart rate catches up.
Short reps of a few minutesPaceHeart rate can lag behind the effort. Don’t speed up just to reach a heart rate target.
A steady run of 20 minutes or morePaceHeart rate checkHeart rate drifts up even at a steady pace. Compare it with your usual range late in similar runs.
Hills, trails or strong windFeelHeart rateYour pace drops uphill and into the wind at the same effort.
A hot or humid dayFeelHeart rateHeat slows you down and pushes heart rate up. Expect a slower pace.

Data: Fleckenstein et al., 2023; Ely et al., 2007; Minetti et al., 2002.

How do the pros do it?

Some of the world’s best distance runners, like the Ingebrigtsen brothers of Norway, take it a step further. During threshold sessions, they prick a finger every few reps to measure their lactate. Then they set their pace to keep it in a fairly low, narrow range. They track heart rate as well.12

Blood tests show whether lactate is staying in the range the coach has set. The same review notes that the link between heart rate and lactate differs from runner to runner. It even changes for the same runner across a season.12 Most of us don’t carry a lactate meter. For everyday training, pace, heart rate and feel give you practical ways to judge the effort.

How should you run your next threshold workout?

Start with an estimate of your threshold pace from a recent race. Our free pace zone calculator estimates your training paces, including threshold, from that result. Then pick one of the sessions below to suit your training and the conditions.

Use time rather than distance to keep the workout manageable at any pace. Four to five 1-mile reps take 32–45 minutes at an 8–9 minute mile pace. The shorter reps below give you 15–20 minutes of threshold running.

These are examples to build toward, not a minimum: do fewer reps if you’re new to this work or running low weekly mileage. Warm up with easy running and cool down afterward. Coach Jack Daniels’ training guidance also emphasizes keeping threshold sessions modest relative to your weekly mileage.

Flat route, normal day

Threshold reps

3–4 × 5 minutes, jog 1 minute between

Run at your estimated threshold pace. Start with three reps; build to four as you get used to the session. Keep the effort controlled through the last rep.

Go by pace

Continuous effort

Tempo run

20 minutes at threshold

Try this once you’re comfortable with shorter reps. Start at your estimated threshold pace, and ease off if the effort becomes strained.

Pace, with heart rate as a check

Hills or a hot day

By feel

3 × 5 minutes, jog 1 minute between

Let the pace slow as needed to keep the effort controlled. Use heart rate as a check. In tough conditions, shorten the workout or make it an easy run.

Feel, with heart rate as a check

A new race result can help you update your threshold pace. If the same workout feels easier across several similar days, it may also be time to reassess. One unusually easy run isn’t enough on its own.

What are the limits of this research?

1

The studies are small. Several of the running studies tested just 7 to 31 people, many of them young and already fit.

2

Most were done on treadmills in a lab, where the weather never changes and there are no hills.

3

Labs measure threshold in different ways. The 40-minute study set pace at a blood lactate level of 2 millimoles per liter. That is not the same as finding each runner’s highest steady lactate level. Treat numbers like “84% to 91% of max” as a guide, not a rule.

4

Some points come from coaching experience, like heart rate lagging in short reps. We couldn’t find a study that measured it in runners’ own workouts.

Our take: let pace lead on good days, let heart rate tell you when a day is harder than it looks, and trust how it feels. On hills or hot days, slow down enough to keep the effort controlled.

Common questions

Should I run threshold by pace or heart rate?

On a flat route in normal weather, go by pace. Use your estimated threshold pace to settle into a steady effort. Check it against how you feel and your usual heart rate range late in similar runs. On hills, trails, windy or hot days, run by feel and let the pace slow as needed.

What heart rate is threshold?

It differs from runner to runner. In one study, trained runners’ heart rates at a fixed blood lactate level ranged from 84% to 91% of their max. That doesn’t give everyone a threshold heart rate. For a practical guide, note your usual range late in controlled threshold runs on flat ground in cool weather.

Why does my heart rate keep rising during a tempo run?

That’s called cardiac drift. Heart rate creeps up over a long effort even when your pace stays the same, and heat and losing fluid make it worse. In one study, runners’ heart rates rose from about 88% to 92% of max over 40 minutes at a steady speed based on a lab lactate test, while their oxygen use barely changed.

Do I need a chest strap for heart rate training?

If heart rate guides your workouts, a chest strap helps. In a 2017 test, a chest strap matched a medical ECG almost perfectly, while wrist monitors were less accurate and varied by brand and activity.

Sources

  1. 1
    Faude O, Kindermann W, Meyer T. Lactate threshold concepts: how valid are they? Sports Med, 2009. doi:10.2165/00007256-200939060-00003
  2. 2
    Nixon RJ, Kranen SH, Vanhatalo A, Jones AM. Steady-state V̇O₂ above MLSS: evidence that critical speed better represents maximal metabolic steady state in well-trained runners. Eur J Appl Physiol, 2021. doi:10.1007/s00421-021-04780-8
  3. 3
    Fleckenstein D, Seelhöfer J, Walter N, Ueberschär O. From incremental test to continuous running at fixed lactate thresholds: individual responses on %VO2max, %HRmax, lactate accumulation, and RPE. Sports, 2023. doi:10.3390/sports11100198
  4. 4
    Coyle EF, González-Alonso J. Cardiovascular drift during prolonged exercise: new perspectives. Exerc Sport Sci Rev, 2001. doi:10.1097/00003677-200104000-00009
  5. 5
    Wingo JE, Stone T, Ng J. Cardiovascular drift and maximal oxygen uptake during running and cycling in the heat. Med Sci Sports Exerc, 2020. doi:10.1249/mss.0000000000002324
  6. 6
    Montain SJ, Coyle EF. Influence of graded dehydration on hyperthermia and cardiovascular drift during exercise. J Appl Physiol, 1992. doi:10.1152/jappl.1992.73.4.1340
  7. 7
    Vobejda C, Fromme K, Samson W, Zimmermann E. Maximal constant heart rate: a heart rate based method to estimate maximal lactate steady state in running. Int J Sports Med, 2006. doi:10.1055/s-2005-865717
  8. 8
    Gillinov S, Etiwy M, Wang R, et al. Variable accuracy of wearable heart rate monitors during aerobic exercise. Med Sci Sports Exerc, 2017. doi:10.1249/mss.0000000000001284
  9. 9
    Minetti AE, Moia C, Roi GS, Susta D, Ferretti G. Energy cost of walking and running at extreme uphill and downhill slopes. J Appl Physiol, 2002. doi:10.1152/japplphysiol.01177.2001
  10. 10
    Ely MR, Cheuvront SN, Roberts WO, Montain SJ. Impact of weather on marathon-running performance. Med Sci Sports Exerc, 2007. doi:10.1249/mss.0b013e31802d3aba
  11. 11
    Foster C, Florhaug JA, Franklin J, et al. A new approach to monitoring exercise training. J Strength Cond Res, 2001. doi:10.1519/1533-4287(2001)015<0109:ANATME>2.0.CO;2
  12. 12
    Casado A, Foster C, Bakken M, Tjelta LI. Does lactate-guided threshold interval training within a high-volume low-intensity approach represent the “next step” in the evolution of distance running training? Int J Environ Res Public Health, 2023. doi:10.3390/ijerph20053782

This article is general information, not medical advice. Check with a doctor before starting hard training if you have a health condition or are coming back from an injury.